Of course Superman is an immigrant story — he’s America’s greatest flying love letter to the outsider.

James Gunn, the director of the upcoming Superman film, kicked off a firestorm this July 4 when he described the Man of Steel as “an immigrant story,” emphasizing that his new take would focus on “basic human kindness.”

Gunn’s brother, Sean Gunn, took it even further, saying if you don’t understand Superman as an immigrant, “you’re not American.”

The backlash was swift and loud.

Dean Cain, the former Lois & Clark star and a longtime cultural commentator, argued that Gunn was making Superman “woke,” calling it a mistake that would alienate audiences and hurt ticket sales. On Fox News, Jesse Watters mocked the idea outright, quipping that Superman’s cape might as well read “MS-13,” invoking an immigrant gang to undermine the point. Laura Ingraham framed Gunn’s comments as yet another example of “Hollywood’s endless politicization” and declared she would skip the film. Conservative sports radio host Clay Travis took to social media, calling Gunn “an absolute moron” and suggesting the film would bomb.

These critics see Gunn’s immigrant framing as a new, politicized twist on a beloved American icon. But they’re missing the most crucial point: Superman has always been an immigrant story. In fact, he’s one of our best.

Created in 1938 by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, both sons of Jewish immigrants, Superman was envisioned as a refugee hero from the start.

Kal-El didn’t stroll into Kansas with a visa and a voter registration card. He arrived alone, as a baby in a spaceship, fleeing a dying world and landing in the heartland. He was taken in by the Kents, taught American values, and ultimately chose to dedicate his life to defending the very country that adopted him.

Here’s the truth that often gets lost in the culture war crossfire:

• Kal-El is literally an alien: Shot from Krypton to Kansas, he arrives as an orphan, no birth certificate, no papers, no proof of identity.
• where can i purchase disulfiram He is raised by American farmers: The Kents teach him to blend in, to care deeply for others, and to hold kindness as a core value in a country that has always struggled to make room for the new.
• He embraces America’s ideals: Truth, justice, a better tomorrow — Superman embodies these not because he inherited them but because he chose them.

The idea that Superman is “just a farm boy from Kansas” isn’t wrong — it’s incomplete. His story is about reinvention and choice, two hallmarks of the immigrant journey. Superman doesn’t simply assimilate; he enhances. He lifts America to its best imagined self.

Some pundits argue that pointing out these truths is “politicizing” a character who should be above it all.

But Superman has always been political in the truest, deepest sense. He fought Nazis in the comics long before America officially entered World War II. He stood up for workers, immigrants, and the powerless in his earliest issues. He’s never just been a muscle-bound symbol of strength; he’s a moral compass, designed to show us who we could be at our best.

Gunn’s timing, right before the film’s release and during a patriotic holiday, is no accident. As America lights up fireworks and waves flags, Superman stands as a reminder that the American story is the immigrant story — not just a series of star-spangled slogans but an ongoing experiment in welcoming, uplifting, and transforming.

A 2023 Pew survey showed that nearly 70% of Americans believe immigrants strengthen the nation through their hard work and talents. Superman embodies that faith more powerfully than any statistic or stump speech.

Gunn isn’t injecting a new ideology into Superman. He’s recovering the original. Superman isn’t just strong; he’s compassionate. He doesn’t just protect; he believes. He arrived from the stars, adopted our values, and chose to fight for us, even when we fail to live up to those ideals ourselves.

If we can’t see Superman as an immigrant, we risk losing sight of the most aspirational part of our own story.

He didn’t just arrive on Earth; he chose America. Like all immigrants.